Home
Macedonia

State Lottery trial continues as expert Anita Popovska is cross‑examined

Defense for Artan Grubi questioned the Bureau for Public Procurement and Ministry of Finance roles in the video‑lottery terminal procurement.

·Macedonia
State Lottery trial continues as expert Anita Popovska is cross‑examined

The evidentiary phase in the State Lottery case in the Basic Criminal Court in Skopje continued today with the cross‑examination of expert witness Anita Popovska by the defence of the second accused, Artan Grubi. The procurement of video lottery terminals is at the centre of the indictment, which names Grubi, former director Perparim Bajrami and six other defendants.

Defence lawyer Vladimir Donevski focused his questions on the competences of the Bureau for Public Procurement and the Ministry of Finance in procedures related to the procurement. Popovska said her work examined whether administrative control had verified compliance with the rules and procedures of the Public Procurement Law.

Popovska answered: "The primary role of administrative control was to verify whether, in conducting the procedure, the rules and procedures of the Public Procurement Law were observed."

Expert scope and ministry opinion

When asked whether the Bureau could initiate misdemeanor or criminal proceedings, Popovska said she did not know which other instruments were envisaged and that her expert analysis followed normative rules related to drawing financial conclusions. She told the court: "I think the question is empty. As I stated, I follow exclusively the norms regarding drawing conclusions from a financial aspect, but which are those other instruments, I do not know."

Defence counsel also questioned her about a payment allegedly made on 26 September 2025 following a change in management at the State Lottery; Popovska said she did not know when the management change occurred. She confirmed that the Ministry of Finance's opinion concerned the need for the State Lottery to undertake activities to provide games of chance and that the Ministry had invoked Article 7(3) of the Law on Games of Chance. Popovska added: "The laws, yes, in the normative part, but I have not taken the Rules of Procedure into account. I do not understand the questions regarding the opinion of the Ministry of Finance. To obtain an opinion from the Ministry of Finance, there are forms that are signed. Let's take them out and see which forms relate to the submitted requests."

Prosecutors objected when the defence cited Articles 25 and 26 of the Law on Games of Chance, arguing the question contained legal conclusions and that an economic expert should not be asked to confirm legal provisions — a matter for closing arguments and evidence analysis. The court overruled the objection.

At a previous hearing Popovska described the scope of her expert report as the procurement procedure for the video lottery terminals from planning and tendering through framework agreements, equipment delivery and payments. She stated the total amount paid for the procurement was 596,125,511 denars and that no separate contracts, deliveries, invoicing or payments were established for the third selected economic operator.

Besides Grubi and Bajrami, the accused are Bashkim Avdi, Metodija Dimovski, Skender Mehmeti, Bojan Janev, Fatmir Ramadanovski and Aleksandar Dimitrioski. The indictment alleges that by exceeding official powers they caused damage to AD State Lottery in the amount of 596,125,511 denars. All defendants have pleaded not guilty.

The prosecution is led by Daniel Kocev and Aleksandar Davchevski, and the trial is being conducted by Judge Biljana Suplinovska‑Jovevski.

Photo: press material from the event

Related articles