Criticism of Zinedine Zidane after Italy defeat and shaky win over Turkey
Defeat by Italy (1-3) and a narrow 2-1 victory over Turkey sparked questions about tactics, midfield balance and the form of key players.

Zinedine Zidane’s start as France coach has hit its first turbulence despite the team reaching the Nations League quarter-finals. A heavy 1-3 defeat by Italy and a narrow 2-1 win over Turkey provoked sharp criticism from French pundits and raised questions about tactical choices, midfield balance and the form of key players.
RMC Sport’s After Foot pinpoints weaknesses
Analysts on RMC Sport’s program After Foot said Zidane’s initial goodwill is fading and warned the coach must address a string of concrete problems before the next international window. “Zidane has hit a wall of reality during his second cycle,” they said, calling attention to the side’s struggles when out of possession and to questionable selections.
The broadcast singled out the midfield as an area of concern, arguing France lacked the balance and resilience needed against better-organised opponents. When pressed in the second half against Italy and at stages in the Turkey match, the French central units struggled to cope with pressure—an issue that must be solved ahead of the Nations League quarter-final in March.
Individual performances also came under fire. Michael Olise was described as “completely invisible” while Ryan Cherki left the camp with more doubts than at his arrival, despite being touted as a future leader. Lucas da Cunha earned praise for his showing, but using Cherki in a right-back or right-sided link role baffled many critics.
The main points raised by commentators were: weak displays from key players such as Michael Olise and Ryan Cherki; lack of midfield balance, especially without the ball; unconvincing tactical choices like deploying Cherki in a right-sided linking role; and problems with some players’ mentality during the Turkey game.
Despite the criticism, Zidane still benefits from time and the fact that France secured a place in the quarter-finals. Those inside French football will expect clearer answers in March, when the coach must show whether recent difficulties are simply part of a transition or signs of deeper issues.
Photo: press material from the event


