Home
Politics

Filipche warns about the second pension pillar: who will bear the risk for Chebren?

Filipche calls for clear safeguards for second-pillar personal savings before any possible investment in state projects.

·Politics
Filipche warns about the second pension pillar: who will bear the risk for Chebren?

SDSM leader Venko Filipche called for personal savings in the second pension pillar not to be exposed to state capital-project risk without clear safeguards, independent assessments and accountability for possible losses. At a press conference in Parliament on October 1, he responded to PIOM director Nikola Memov’s proposal to consider a legal option for private pension funds to invest in projects such as Chebren and Galiste.

What is being proposed, and what applies today

On September 28, in an appearance on Telma television, Memov outlined an idea for legal amendments that would allow private managers of mandatory pension funds—the second pillar—to invest part of their assets in domestic capital projects. He explicitly mentioned the Chebren and Galiste hydropower projects. This is a proposal, not an adopted law: no draft law or binding investment decision was presented. The proposal does not provide for the seizure or transfer of money from insured persons’ individual accounts to the state.

Memov said there would be risk-based profiles, MAPAS supervision, and a goal of diversification and higher returns. He also cited indicative figures: about 640,000 insured persons and more than EUR 300 million that, according to him, flow annually into the second pillar. Those statements describe his idea for a possible legal framework; they are not a decision to make a specific investment.

In a statement to Deutsche Welle in June, MAPAS said that the assets of mandatory private pension funds have been growing continuously and that long-term returns are within expectations. Second-pillar assets are the property of individual insured persons and are separate from the first pillar, through which PIOM, using current contributions and budget support, pays today’s pensions. That distinction is fundamental when assessing any future investment change.

Filipche seeks protection from project risk; Memov explains the proposal

Filipche urged the government not to reach for second-pillar money and warned that investments in domestic projects could expose savers to risk. His warning does not mean that assets have already been seized or invested; it calls for the risk of a potential project failure not to fall on individual pension accounts without safeguards being set in advance. The question he raises is who would be accountable if a project is delayed, halted or fails to deliver the expected revenue.

Memov, for his part, said current pensions are not at risk and that expanding permitted investments could, under MAPAS supervision, bring diversification and higher returns. That is his rationale for considering the idea, not a guarantee that a particular project will be safe or profitable. This is why Filipche’s request for clear limits, accountability and protection for savers remains central before any legislative procedure is opened.

Transfers, the “deficit,” and two different pension functions

Filipche also warned about a growing fiscal burden and referred to an increased “deficit.” Memov responded that the annual 2026 transfer of about 64 billion denars is not a pure pension deficit but an aggregate which, according to him, also includes healthcare and so-called transition costs from the introduction of the second pillar. This is an important qualification: the transfer figure itself is not the same as an independently established net deficit of PIOM.

The two statements address different aspects of the system. The first pillar pays today’s pensions, while the second pillar accumulates funds in individual accounts for future pensions. The fiscal-burden debate therefore does not remove the need for specific protection of second-pillar assets, which Filipche has called for, nor does it change the legal separation of the two pillars.

Safeguards to establish before any possible amendments

Investing pension assets in capital projects carries real investment risk: the outcome depends on the risk profile, transparency, independent valuation and the terms under which returns would be achieved. MAPAS has said existing assets are growing and long-term returns are within expectations; that is not a substitute for assessing the risk of each future project. Filipche is calling for those safeguards to be in place before personal savings are considered for new types of investment.

Before any possible draft law, the public needs answers on whether fund participation would be voluntary and subject to what limits; who would decide on each investment; how independent assessments would be performed and conflicts of interest prevented when the state initiates a project; and whether guarantees or a clear mechanism to limit losses on individual accounts would exist. Memov’s publicly presented proposal did not include a draft law or a binding investment decision.

While MAPAS assesses second-pillar performance as being within expectations, Filipche’s request is for project risk and accountability to be publicly and precisely regulated before any change. Until then, this remains a proposal that should be tested through a transparent legislative and regulatory procedure, without affecting ownership of individual accounts.

Sources and context: SDSM (press conference); Telma (Memov’s proposal); 4News (budget-transfer explanation); Deutsche Welle (MAPAS position).

Photo: frame from the SDSM press conference

Related articles